Miami vs Key West: Which Is Better For Your Vacation In 2024?

Miami vs Key West: Which Is Better For Your Vacation?

Miami 

The vibrant city of Miami is filled with world-famous beaches, pulsating nightlife, and diverse cultural experiences await! 

Miami is known as the Magic City for so many reasons, from its amazing entertainment, dynamic activities, and historical attractions. 

Miami promises a great escape for travelers seeking excitement and glamorous activities in the Sunshine State, which we’ll unpack in this blog post. 

Key West 

Located in the southernmost tip of the United States, Key West offers laid-back island vibes and amazing hidden gems you don’t want to miss. 

Prepare yourself for some exhilarating experiences and water sports, from snorkeling in crystal clear waters to exploring its unique shops and low key bars.

With its amazing beaches and state parks, and a unique blend of culture and cuisine, Key West provides an amazing experience for everyone! 

Miami vs Key West: Things To Do 

Things To Do In Miami 

• Visit South Beach: The first stop is this iconic beach in Miami. Go for a walk on the beautiful Ocean Drive or swim in the turquoise waters of South Beach. 

• Go on a food and walking tour in Little Havana: Immerse yourself in the rich flavors and vibrant atmosphere of Little Havana on a food and walking tour. 

• Arts and Culture in Wynwood Walls: Marvel at the stunning murals in this outdoor street art museum in Miami or ride a golf cart for the best experience.

• Book a Sightseeing Cruise: Sail along the scenic coastline of Miami and catch a glimpse of its iconic landmarks on a sunset cruise. 

• Book a Helicopter Tour: For the ultimate thrill, why not take the skies on a Miami helicopter tour? It’s a great way to experience the city from a different perspective. 

Things To Do In Key West 

• Explore Duval Street: Right in the heart of Key West, this popular spot for tourists offers a bustling energy, lined with diverse shops, lively bars, and mouthwatering eateries.  

• Visit Mallory Square: No trip to Key West is complete without visiting Mallory Square. Join the nightly Sunset Celebration, where locals and visitors gather to witness street performers, artisans, and a breathtaking sunset over the Gulf of Mexico. 

• Tour the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum: Explore the historic home of the famous American writer Ernest Hemingway and learn about his literary legacy while enjoying the gardens filled with cats. 

• Snorkel or Dive at Dry Tortugas National Park: Embark on underwater adventures such as snorkeling or diving excursions and discover vibrant coral reefs, shipwrecks, and diverse marine life. 

• Take a sunset cruise: Set sail aboard a luxurious catamaran or traditional boat while sipping cocktails as you witness stunning sunsets in the waters of Key West. 

Miami vs Key West: Nearby Attractions 

Nearby Attractions In Miami 

• Everglades National Park: Escape into the sprawling wilderness of the Everglades through a thrilling airboat tour and encounter a wide array of wildlife and ecosystems in Florida. 

• Fort Lauderdale: Indulge in leisurely strolls along Las Olas Boulevard or set sail on a relaxing yacht cruise along the Intracoastal Waterway. 

• Biscayne National Park: For crystal-clear waters and vibrant coral reefs, Biscayne National Park is a great spot. Enjoy snorkeling, scuba diving, or just relaxing on the pristine beach. 

• Sanibel Island: Known for its white sandy beaches and abundant shells, this barrier island is a perfect place to unwind and enjoy a more laid-back atmosphere from Miami. 

• West Palm Beach: West Palm Beach is a haven for art and culture enthusiasts. Explore the city’s lively streets, lined with upscale shops, and cozy cafes.  

Nearby Attractions In Key West 

• Bahia Honda State Park: Have a great time while soaking in the breathtaking scenery of crystal-clear waters and pristine beaches and enjoy amazing activities such as snorkeling or kayaking in this paradise located in the Florida Keys. 

• John Pennekamp Coral Reef State Park: Located in the Dive Capital of the World, Key Largo, prepare your snorkel gear or hop on a glass bottom boat as you explore and dive into the state park’s underwater wonders. 

• Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park: Built in the mid-19th century, this historic landmark offers a fascinating glimpse into the history and culture of Key West with nature trails offering panoramic views of the coastline. 

• Islamorada: Experience fishing at its best in the World’s Sport Fishing Capital. Charter a boat for a deep-sea fishing excursion whether you’re an experience fisherman or not. 

• Big Pine Key: Home to the adorable and endangered Key deer. Embark on a wildlife safari to catch a glimpse of these charming creatures in their natural habitat. 

Miami vs Key West: Free & Cheap Things To Do 

Cheap Things To Do In Miami 

• Explore the Vizcaya Museum and Gardens: Step back in time and wander through the stunning European-inspired villa and lush gardens of this hidden gem. 

• Discover the Miami Design District: Explore arts and culture in this creative neighborhood and browse through unique boutiques, and take photos at some of the insta-worthy street art. 

• Shop at Bayside Marketplace: This waterfront destination offers endless entertainment options, from souvenir shopping to enjoying live music and street performances. 

• Stroll down Calle Ocho: Located at the heart of Little Havana, Calle Ocho is a must-visit if you’re looking for authentic Cuban restaurants and cafes. 

• Visit South Pointe Park: This scenic oasis at the southern tip of Miami Beach offers stunning ocean views, walking paths, and a fishing pier.  

Cheap Things To Do In Key West 

• Explore Key West Historic Seaport: Wander through the cobblestone streets filled with shops, seafood restaurants, and iconic landmarks. 

• Visit the Southernmost Point Buoy: Nestled at the southernmost tip of the United States, this attraction is a perfect spot to take selfies and capture amazing ocean views stretching out before you. 

• Wildlife encounter at Key West Wildlife Center: This sanctuary is home to a variety of native wildlife, including birds, reptiles, and mammals giving the opportunity to get up close and personal with some of Florida’s most fascinating creatures. 

• Key West First Legal Rum Distillery Tour: Learn about the island’s rum-making heritage as you explore this legendary distillery and sample some of its delicious, handcrafted spirits. 

Miami vs Key West: Which Is Best For Families Or Couples?

Miami and Key West both offer unique experiences for families and couples, but each destination has its own distinct charm.

​Deciding which one is the best between the two boils down to your travel companions and preferences.

Let’s weigh the options! 

Miami 

We already know that Miami boasts beautiful family-friendly beaches, but the area also impresses with its Art Deco architecture and diverse culinary scenes, perfect for couples seeking adventure and pleasure. 

For families seeking a vibrant mix of culture, activities, and attractions, Miami emerges as a top contender.

Key West 

Key West, on the other hand, offers a laid-back island vibe and picturesque sunsets perfect for couples looking for a romantic setting. 

Couples can find plenty of adults-only accommodations in Key West for a more intimate and memorable stay.

Families can explore historic sites or enjoy family-friendly activities such as snorkeling, kayaking, and wildlife encounters. 

Miami vs Key West: Better Events During The Year? 

When it comes to events and festivals, Miami and Key West each offer their own distinct flair. 

Miami dazzles with its renowned music festivals, art fairs, and cultural celebrations. 

Meanwhile, Key West charms visitors with quirky festivals, celebrating everything from seafood to literary legends. 

Events In Miami 

• Coconut Grove Arts Festival (February): A celebration of Miami’s creativity and artistic expression set against the lush greenery of the charming streets of Coconut Grove. 

• Miami International Boat Show (February): Experience the world’s largest boat and yacht show which takes place in 6 different locations in Miami. 

• South Beach Jazz Festival (January): Listen to soulful melodies and jazz rhythms from world-famous jazz musicians in South Beach. 

• ULTRA Music Festival (March): One of the famous festivals in Miami, where electronic beats and vibrant energy collide as thousands of people dance the night away to the beats of top DJs and performers. 

• Calle Ocho Music Festival (March): Experience Miami’s rich Hispanic heritage and cultural diversity as you try authentic street foods while salsa dancing.

Events In Key West 

• Key Lime Festival (July): Indulge yourself with delicious Key Lime pies, refreshing cocktails, and culinary creations that showcase the signature flavor of the Florida Keys. 

• Key West Food and Wine Festival (January): This festival in Key West features exquisite wines, gourmet cuisines, and local delicacies crafted by top chefs from around the world. 

• Key West Lobsterfest (August): Lobsterfest celebrates the opening of lobster season in Key West featuring fresh lobster dishes, live music, and fun street parties. 

• Fantasy Fest (October): This colorful celebration transforms the streets of Key West into a carnival of costumes and parades.

• Hemingway Days (July): This literary festival pays homage to the works of the iconic author Ernest Hemingway. 

Miami vs Key West: Best Restaurants In Each City

Best Places To Eat In Miami 

• Stubborn Seed: From the exquisite tasting menu to handcrafted cocktails, every detail makes an elevated dining experience. 

• CRAFT Brickell: For those looking for a taste of local flavor, this trendy restaurant showcases the best of Miami’s craft beer scene, with an impressive selection of brews on tap and famous American dishes. 

• Mofongo Restaurant Calle 8: Located in Little Havana, this charming eatery serves delicious authentic Latin cuisine in Miami with a warm atmosphere. 

• Pummarola Midtown: This popular pizzeria in Miami specializes in Neapolitan-style pizza, with a menu featuring classic pies and creative toppings that will delight every pizza lover. 

Best Places To Eat In Key West 

• Santiago’s Bodega: Indulge yourselves in an array of Spanish cuisine bursting with flavor in this beloved tapas bar in Key West.  

• Tavern N Town: A sophisticated tapas bar and steakhouse in Key West serving fresh seafood, steaks, and handcrafted desserts with live music and an elegant ambiance. 

• Hot Tin Roof: Located atop the Ocean Key Resort & Spa on Duval Street, this waterfront restaurant offers Latin American-inspired dishes with open-air patios and a panoramic view of the Gulf of Mexico. 

• Seaside Cafe at the Mansion: This charming cafe serves delicious breakfast and lunch in a relaxed setting for a more casual dining experience in Key West. 

• Kaya Island Eats: A cozy restaurant that specializes in Pacific and Caribbean-inspired cuisine with a focus on bold flavors and fresh local ingredients. 

Should You Stay In Miami Or Key West? 

Best Places To Stay In Miami

1. THE HOUSE ZEN SANCTUARY

The Tree House Zen Sanctuary is a budget-friendly apartment located just 2.2km from the Vizcaya Museum and Gardens. 

This apartment features 1 bedroom and bathroom with amenities including a television with streaming services, a fully equipped kitchen and dining, and a private parking area. 

They can accommodate up to 4 guests, ideal for those who are traveling in a group or with kids. 

2. Hotel Ponce de Leon

For couples traveling on a budget, the Hotel Ponce de Leon situated in Coral Gables is an ideal choice. 

With an excellent and safe location, this small hotel is just a few steps away from nearby bars and restaurants. 

The rooms are quite simple; however, they offer amenities including a microwave, a coffee machine, and a flat-screen TV, which is reasonable for its price. 

3. The Elser Hotel Miami

Take advantage of the hot tub and fully equipped rooms with a terrace to relax while enjoying the city views of Miami. 

Although it was pricey, many guests loved the overall experience including the style, the atmosphere, and the impeccable service. 

Best Places To Stay In Key West

1. The Cabana Inn Key West – Adult Exclusive

Guests can enjoy a complimentary continental breakfast during their stay.  

With an excellent location just a 1-minute walk from Duval Street and 13 minutes away from the Southernmost Point. 

2. Key West Bed And Breakfast

If you’re looking for a relaxing place to stay with a cozy and warm ambiance, the Key West Bed and Breakfast is a great option. 

Take advantage of the free breakfast and enjoy the beautiful gardens that surround the property. 

Guests love the cute furniture and designs in every room, and the location is great since it is just close and walkable to different attractions in Key West. 

3. The Capitana Key West

For an upscale stay and relaxation, The Capitana Key West hotel is an ideal option. 

Situated on a gorgeous beachfront with stunning ocean views, this 4-star hotel offers an outdoor swimming pool, a restaurant, a fitness center, and a terrace. 

The rooms are also comfortable and spacious, with excellent amenities including a hot tub. 

Miami vs Key West: Which City Has Better Beaches? 

Well, it all depends on what ambiance and experiences you’re looking for at a beach. 

Both cities have their own unique charms and let me tell you, the choice of the best beach isn’t an easy one.

If you crave the best nightlife and entertainment, the bustling beach scene in Miami is your best choice. 

If you prefer more island vibes and charm, then Key West has you covered. 

Best Beaches In Miami 

• South Beach: On top of the list, South Beach is a playground for sun-seekers who love to party and chill.  Enjoy the turquoise waters of the beach and art deco architecture in Ocean Drive, or catch some waves and try surfing. 

• Surfside Beach: This hidden gem is a great option in Miami if you prefer a more serene beach experience. Offering a pristine beach perfect for swimming and snorkeling. 

• Mid-Beach, Miami Beach: Just a little further up the coast lies Mid-Beach, where you’ll find a beautiful stretch of beach lined with bars, hotels, and trendy eateries. 

• Bal Harbour Beach: Offering calm beaches and upscale shopping, this beach is renowned for its crystal-clear waters, and exclusive shopping boutiques in Miami. 

• Sunny Isles Beach: Nestled between the Atlantic Ocean and Intracoastal Waterway, this picturesque paradise is a favorite among families and beachgoers. 

Best Beaches In Key West 

• Dog Beach: This hidden gem in Key West is a haven for furry friends and their owners alike. Your dogs are allowed to run on the beach but keep an eye on them because some areas can be rocky and slippery. 

• Smathers Beach: is the largest public beach in Key West known for its calm waters and spectacular sunsets. Smather Beach is ideal for swimming, snorkeling, kayaking, and beach volleyball. 

• Higgs Beach: Located on the Atlantic Ocean, this beach is an ideal spot for history and culture in Key West. Take a stroll along the scenic promenade and find the iconic West Martello Tower standing guard over the shoreline.  

• South Beach – Key West: Situated at the southern end of Duval Street, this beach is one of the smallest public beaches in Key West. Catch the sunrise early in the morning to beat the crowds and eat lunch at one of the cafes in the area. 

• Simonton Street Beach: Nestled in Old Town Key West, this charming small beach offers soft sand and small beach chairs. It is also a great place to watch the sunset in Key West. 

Miami vs Key West Frequently Asked Questions 

Is Key West Worth A Day Trip From Miami? 

Absolutely! Go on a scenic Key West drive along the stunning Overseas Highway, approximately 159 miles southwest of Miami.

Spend your day exploring historic landmarks, snorkeling or diving at the beaches and national parks, or indulge in delicious seafood delights. 

Is Key West Or Miami Hotter? 

Generally, Key West tends to be slightly warmer than Miami due to its southernmost location in the Florida Keys. 

However, the temperature difference between the two cities is slightly minimal. 

Both destinations boast tropical climates with warm temperatures year-round. 

Is Key West More Expensive Than Miami? 

This might surprise you, but Key West tends to be pricier than Miami in many aspects. 

Accommodation, dining, and outdoor activities in Key West often come with a higher price tag due to its popularity as a tourist destination and limited space. 

Its remote location in the Gulf of Mexico also demands costly product imports. 

Is It Better To Fly In Miami Or Key West? 

It depends on your itinerary. If you’re exploring solely Key West, flying directly there can save time. 

But if you plan to visit multiple destinations or prefer more flight options, Miami offers greater flexibility. 

Are Flights To Key West More Expensive?

Generally, flights to Key West are expensive due to limited availability and less airlines flying in. 

It’s advisable to compare prices and consider factors like convenience and travel time before booking a flight.

Final Thoughts: Miami vs Key West 

In conclusion, both Miami and Key West offer distinct experiences that cater to different preferences. 

Miami boasts an energetic nightlife, world-class dining, and a diverse cultural scene, for those who are seeking urban excitement and entertainment. 

On the other hand, Key West’s relaxed atmosphere, beautiful beaches, and charming island vibes make it an ideal escape for relaxation and adventure. 

Whichever you choose, I can assure you both destinations will give you a good time and experiences you’ll never forget. 

Additional Miami & Key West Travel Posts